December 13, 2005 in GENRES

THE FAMILY STONE by Caroline


How psyched was I when I saw this trailer for the first (and second, and third) time!? I mean, we’re talking SJP, Diane Keaton, hot hot Dermot Mulroney, my new favorite actress Rachel McAdams, Claire Danes, Luke Wilson – my first thought was, “Oh my God, this is going to be the best movie ever!” After a few minutes though, I had a Debbie Downer moment and realized that there was no way this movie was going to be as good as I wanted it to be. And sadly, I was right. I should have seen this with Ryan because he got a screening pass to it, but he was on a plane from Milwaukee so I went with my friend and colleague, Cheryl. Let me tell you, it was disappointing.

I didn’t have hugely high hopes for Family Stone because with a cast like this, the movie itself becomes anti-climactic – and also, a friend of mine in LA read the script a while ago and said it sucked. The movie is your basic tightly-knit-liberal-New-England-family-meets-son’s-uptight-girlfriend-at-Christmas-and-she-feels-left-out scenario. Throw in a deaf, gay son and someone dying of cancer for good measure. Admittedly, there are some cute scenes, like when SJP escapes with Luke Wilson to the local bar and gets drunk, or any time my girl Rachel is being bitchy. And Diane K is great as always. But the movie wants to be a heart-warming Christmas family dramedy and in reality, it’s just bizarre and muddled. The thing that goes down between Dermot and Sarah Jessica and her sister and Dermot’s brother is so odd that I can’t believe anyone actually conceived of it. The deaf brother smirks a lot and is annoying. And the ending is just cloying and stupid. I didn’t totally hate it, and if you love all these actors and are dying to see it, go ahead for sure. Just don’t expect much.

Thanks For Viewing The THE FAMILY STONE by Caroline