CAPOTE

RYAN: “Capote” we saw at the Chelsea Theater, 23rd Street, with an exclusively gay audience, including one Nathan Lane. What did you think of him?
CAROLINE: Not that remarkable.
RYAN: I thought he was amazing as Capote.
CAROLINE: (laughs)
RYAN: I thought he was so good.
CAROLINE: He just looked like Nathan Lane.
RYAN: He came really late, though. And, quelle suprize, had to sit in like the third row on the right side. Shitty seat.
CAROLINE: We had fabulous seats, on the other hand.
RYAN: Yeah. Cuz we’re notoriously arriving at movies 45 minutes early. You have to in this city.
CAROLINE: Exactly.
RYAN: Ok.
CAROLINE: Ok. Highly anticipated. Oscar buzz for Phil Hoffman. That’s Philip Seymour Hoffman to you people.
RYAN: I had not read “Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil” prior to seeing this film.
CAROLINE: (laughs)
RYAN: But I loved learning the back-story and how interestingly obsessive Capote was in writing it.
CAROLINE: Yes. I filled Yael in on a little bit of the back-story. I have read “In Cold Blood,” and I thought it was great.
RYAN: Now the very first scene… owned me. I thought this film had such a strong opening. It was a riveting, with a capital “V,” opening scene. And then from that moment on, I was so annoyed by Philip’s voice. He apparently nailed the Capote tone and voice, and was very true.
CAROLINE: An imitation.
RYAN: But I have to tell you that it was very grating on me.
CAROLINE: I like him as an actor. But I wanted to be blown away by the movie and I wasn’t.
RYAN: And I thought Catherine Keener was really bland.
CAROLINE: It was a thankless role.
RYAN: And she looked like Nicky Kidman circa… what’s the flick she won the Oscar for?
CAROLINE: Oh. “The Hours.”
RYAN: Yes. Catherine Keener looked like “The Hours.” She looked dour.
CAROLINE: I love Catherine Keener but they gave her nothing to do in this movie.
RYAN: Yes. No makeup. Just real, whatever.
CAROLINE: But the guy who played Perry Smith was very… He looked like Boner from the tv series “Growing Pains.” He looked like him through the entire movie then I looked on imdb.com and found it was a different actor. (laughs)

RYAN: He did a great job. And here’s the thing: I thought it was sick how much Capote was obsessed with the killer. Wow, a twisted love. But I was disappointed in how confusifyingly they revealed Capote with his actual lover.
CAROLINE: Right.
RYAN: When he went away to another country to do some writing, the man he went with…
CAROLINE: You were like, “Who is this man?”
RYAN: Right. The movie was not explicit enough that that was his lover.
CAROLINE: Right.
RYAN: I needed that.
CAROLINE: Well, final thoughts. We agreed it was too long. And way slow. That seems to be a common theme with us lately. Too slow and too long.
RYAN: I was disappointed. Good performances. Not Best Picture.
CAROLINE: Hell no. Hell no.
