BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN

RYAN: So we just saw Buckbeak Mountain.
CAROLINE: I thought there were some excellent scenes. Powerful and I wept. But it was slow…
RYAN: So slow.
CAROLINE: And a lot of the same strummy guitar over and over again. Not the best movie.
RYAN: I actually overall did not like this film. I like what the movie’s doing to mainstream film, i.e. not just dealing with AIDS, as a gay film… I like what that’s doing,
CAROLINE: But this is not a major studio film, it’s low budget relatively.
RYAN: But politically, I appreciate what it’s doing. But still, I was not entertained by this.
CAROLINE: A little slow.
RYAN: Too slow for me, didn’t hold my interest… they’re both hot and also I wanted to see a slow burn…
***SPOILER ALERT*** (Readers who have not yet seen the film, the text below may spoil it for you)
RYAN: I thought they were going to spend a couple of summers atop Buckbeak Mountain, and have a slow burn to their romance. And it turned out to be more like that gudgefuck.

CAROLINE: Yeah. Like I have to say, not to ruin anything, but that first sex scene I was like, ‘Are you kidding me?’ The second one I loved, but the first one I was like, that would never happen. They would cuddle, they might blow each other, but they would never… he wouldn’t just ass fuck him (note to Caroline, when referring to gay sex, you needn’t call it ass fucking…) But the Jake Gyllenhaal character is clearly gay.
RYAN: Right.
CAROLINE: and the Heath Ledger character was like, “Whoa, I’ll try it” but I don’t think he would just eff him like that.
RYAN: Right. Ouch.
CAROLINE: Exactly, ouch, A. And B, give me a slow burn! Maybe one night they just spoon and they’re freaked out by it. So anyway, I was shocked by that. And then the second love scene was amazing. And Michelle Williams!
RYAN: Yeah, Michelle Williams. I think she deserves all the kudos she gets. Anywhilst, one of my favorite actresses, Anne McHathaway, a little disappointed in the hair department.
CAROLINE: Wowzah. Whao, Oh the wigs.
RYAN: She cannot do blonde.
CAROLINE: But it was not her fault. It was someone else’s fault.
RYAN: Yeah, but still, it’s like she’s a cute girl but she didn’t look so cute.
CAROLINE: She has a bit of a puffy lip.

RYAN: But props to her for edging it up… from The Princess Diaries to her first titty appearance.
CAROLINE: And Michelle’s boobs. Double tit action in the movie.
RYAN: And how about, like you said during the film, life imitating art. How did you feel watching Heath & Michelle go at it? Not as hot as Brangelina during Mr. & Mrs. Smith.
CAROLINE: I didn’t notice… Their acting was very good.
RYAN: There shouldn’t have been chemistry because his character didn’t love her.
CAROLINE: He was supposed to be marginally into her but he was supposed to be more into women than Jake was. He was more 60 – 40 straight where Jake was more 90 – 10 gay.
RYAN: Right. So Heath is getting more nominations. But I just walked away calling him Mumbles.
CAROLINE: He talks like Slingblade.
RYAN: He had the harder turn of the two characters. Here’s the thing, they really got all their nuances down. Their spitting, the cowboy swagger.
CAROLINE: Some cinematography in the beginning was very nice, the hills…
RYAN: Yeah and they had to learn how to work with sheep.
CAROLINE: And ride horses and all of it. Anyway, I didn’t hate the movie, but I’m neutral.
RYAN: I didn’t hate it but here’s the thing. I cannot recommend this movie. This is not a must-see. I think it’s an important film and if you want to support the gay agenda, fine. Interesting story. It’s an atypical love story, even for a gay love story. And it’s heart-wrenching.
CAROLINE: But is it a great movie? No.
RYAN: It just didn’t have enough drama. But it was a smart film… It didn’t hit us over the head with anything. We’re allowed to figure things out for ourselves.
CAROLINE: Right. Yeah. I still almost don’t know the all the answers but it kept me thinking… But a lot of the movie was just slow and long.
RYAN: They could have easily cut out 15 minutes and given us more punch to the drama.
CAROLINE: On the one hand I’m not like,”Omg it sucked,” but on the other, I’m not like, “It’s one of the best films this year.” Walk the Line was infinitely better.
RYAN: Well, as a gay in 2005, I didn’t really identify or relate. It’s a real sign of the times film. I appreciate how far we’ve come. Final thoughts?
CAROLINE: I love Ang Lee, but this is not his best work. It was fine. Fine.
RYAN: Unmoved… it’s good movie season, Oscar buzz, our expectations were high.
CAROLINE: Yes we’ve seen better.

Lauryn January 26, 2006
As we discussed, Caroline, I disagree with you and Ryan on this one. Loved Brokeback and didn’t find it slow at all. But, to your point, I do only see about one movie every 6 months now, so I may have been intoxicated by the fake butter on my popcorn. Love the blog!
Anonymous January 27, 2006
Thank you. Thank you. Thankyouthankyou. My thoughts EXACTLY. It’s frustrating to me that no one is saying these things. It is what it is. It’s not bad. It’s not awesome. But don’t make the movie what it ain’t. K
Ryaline (Ryan & Caroline) January 27, 2006
Thanks for reading our blog, Lauryn & K! -Ryaline 😉